Comments on: Where will we find justice for Trayvon Martin?

By: Dale R. Landry

Dale R. Landry — Sat, 21 Apr 2012 20:30:48 +0000

David wonderful review and comments. As a RJ/CJ practitioner and member of the Florida State Conference NAACP Executive Committee, there are individuals at the decision making level within Sanford city government that are aware of and are considering introducing a restorative justice based response in the healing process. As you may be aware, a few years back the National NAACP adopted restorative justice philosophy and have reaffirmed it in more recent years as being essential in re-entry efforts and zero-tolerance approaches within communities. It is in this vein that some of us that are in dialogue with Sanford leadership are recommending a restorative approach as they plan on rebuilding the community.

Just wanted to let you know, RJ and CJ are being considered and thankfully there are advisors in Sanford with a background in RJ that are shaping the healing response.

By: Joanne Kehayas

Joanne Kehayas — Tue, 17 Apr 2012 16:45:17 +0000

I would like to respond to Bill Goldberg’s final question, the one about prevention of future crime. Although the obvious answer would most likely be to find a way to change societal attitudes about different races, I took the question to mean more “What can Resorative Justice do to reduce future crime?”

I would like to point out that if a process under the banner of Restorative Justice were to accomplish the goal of healing the victims (in this case the victim’s family and community), then there would be fewer hurting victims. Many perpetrators are, in fact, victims of previous wrongdoings that have not been healed. Helping to heal hurting victims may in this way, reduce at least a proportion of future crime.

By: Batina Platt

Batina Platt — Mon, 16 Apr 2012 04:17:10 +0000

David,
I’m glad to have read your blog on the Trayvon Davis case. It’s very clear that the media plays a significant role on the hype of this case. Yes we have all become aware of the killing of this teenage boy was senseless and it’s evident that the problem was not Trayvon, but a more serious problem that is exists, racism. I’m pretty sure that whatever fear that George Zimmerman encountered from Trayvon could have certainly been rectified with annoying other than taking his life. At this point Zimmerman has been arrested and charged with the killing of Trayvon, but Im still not sure if he’ll ever be convicted. If in fact the media didn’t make such a major fuss about Trayvon being killed, this would have been a case where a murderer was allowed to live his life freely after taken another person’s. We need to get to the root of the problem in American which is, racism still exists. If there isn’t ever a solution to this problem, then there are going to be plenty more cases that occurs just like this one. Only difference, they all won’t become publicly known.
I hope that from this case that we all as Americans learn that we cant just take another person’s life who isn’t a physical threat, and understand that the real victim is the one who acts out of ignorance from their own lack of reasoning.

By: Latrina Green

Latrina Green — Sun, 15 Apr 2012 04:03:26 +0000

I believe that restorative justice is the way to go, but it will take some special people to accept that route, when they feel they have been let down by a system that took over a month to make an arrest. I, for one, have experienced a slow moving criminal justice system that did not sentence fair and seemed to have a disregard for the loss of life that our family experienced. If my grandmother were still alive, she would say, “Baby, just let the Lord handle it.” This was her thought when her youngest son was murdered. In 1983, before anyone knew of restorative justice, my grandmother had dealt with her hurt and had forgiven the man, and others who were involved, in my uncle’s death.

I think if everyone; Trayvon Martin’s family, George Zimmerman and his family, law enforcement, the media, the community and other active participants could come together to incorporate dialogue, and for negotiation and problem solving. In this case, the situation is so heated and complicated, it may be difficult to get everyone, who is involved, to remain focused on the reason they are participating. I hope for everyone involved, they will be able to sit down and use restorative justice as the means to come to some understanding, even if it is just to hear those few words, “I’m sorry that I have caused your family so much pain.”

By: Bill Goldberg

Bill Goldberg — Fri, 13 Apr 2012 15:01:35 +0000

David.

Thank you for the thoughts and insight.

My one thought is related to the further oddity of a Hispanic man not being prejudiced against. I have seen or heard many people say that were the situation an African-American man killing a white man or another African-American man (or a Hispanic man?), the shooter would have been in jail while this was “sorted out”. But George Zimmerman is not a white man.

My guess is that if it were a Hispanic man killing a white man (or another Hispanic man?), the Hispanic man would also be sitting in jail while the police sorted this out.

And if it was a white man killing an African-American man or a Hispanic man (or probably even another white man if the killer was of an equal or higher socia-economic level), the white man who did the killing would remain free until it was sorted out.

So this situation not only includes an injustice against African-Americans, but almost an indifference to the race of the killer because the victim was African-American and the killer was not African-American. And an indifference to the possible tensions between Hispanics and African-Americans (I have seen nothing on this possibility, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t there).

The web of structural injustice in this situation is as sad as it is complicated and confusing with the overall summary not being “white people are privileged”, but “non-white people are suspect” . . . or more strongly “non-white people are assumed to be guilty”. That is what I find the most sad and I am not sure how society can change that.

While your ideas about justice after the fact are what is needed now to right the relationships in the current situation, my question is this:

“How can we stop the next [fill in race of killer] from killing the next [fill in race of non-white murder victim]?”

By: Nathaly Acuna

Nathaly Acuna — Mon, 09 Apr 2012 18:08:24 +0000

David,

You have offered wonderful insight to this horrific case that has now become such a huge part of the criminal justice system and the way in which people see it. As if justice hasnt been something that people have always felt they have had to fight for, this really does more damage to a system that already seems broken. This case really seems to emphasize the fact that race and color still play a major role in our society and thus leads people to commit such violent and terrifing acts without fully thinking of the consequences or who they’re hurting in the process. Altough we cant necessarily pin point the reasons behind the actions, there isnt much left to the imagination but to assume this being the worst motive.

By: Edward White

Edward White — Fri, 06 Apr 2012 19:28:19 +0000

We will find justice for Travon and too many others like him when we realize we do not live in a free America if anyone is subject to what Travon experienced.

When enough people truly want America to be like we boast that it is, a majority will step forward and demand the repeal of permissive gun laws and the utterly stupid “stand your ground” laws.

Unfortunately nothing seems to shock us anymore. Look at Virgonia Tech a couple of yearsd ago.Too many Anericans still dream of the wild west days and think we are still living in them.To them a return to shootouts would solve all problems.

By: Charito Calvachi-Mateyko

Charito Calvachi-Mateyko — Fri, 06 Apr 2012 02:37:24 +0000

Yes, somebody from the restorative community needed to speak up and I am glad that person is you, David. To contemplate the possibility of restorative justice in this case takes people to envision how “justice” could have another meaning rather than just punishment. It takes to envision that this beautiful word “justice” can and should also mean healing the wounds of crime.

Now, Odessa, with your enthusiasm, please, see that restorative justice goes to the roots of the what happen using profound and respectful dialogue. This is not mediation. This is not about who gets what. This is about who we are when conflict and crime hits home.

By: Dr. Murray Riggins

Dr. Murray Riggins — Thu, 05 Apr 2012 20:54:25 +0000

Thanks David. I appreciate your insight and perspective. However, I can’t help but wonder if I flipped the script would the same events play out.

What do you think would happen if a black man “stood his ground” while pursuing a white teenager wearing a hoodie walking in the neighborhood – apparently appearing out of place; and shot to death this unarmed white teenager. Do you think this adult black man would be arrested?

By: Odessa Hooker

Odessa Hooker — Thu, 05 Apr 2012 20:30:38 +0000

This response shows wise discernment regarding a senseless killing. As a mediator, should you volunteer to mediate a healing response for all parties? And, what about an appeal to a higher power: could prayer provide a opening action in the matter?
Do you think the authorities of Sanford, FL would offer to underwrite restorative justice sessions for the involved parties? That action would initiate healing for the whole community.