Editor’s Note: This profile is the fifth of six stories about students and alumni leading up to the 10th annual Lov91Ƶ Giving Day on April 1. For more information about the day and how to donate, visit .
Bethany Chupp ’16, MA ’18 (counseling), remembers the exact moment she learned she had landed 91Ƶ’s prized four-year, full-tuition Yoder/Webb Scholarship.
While on her way to get pizza with a friend’s family, she received a call from History Professor Mark Metzler Sawin, director of 91Ƶ’s Honors program, who told her the good news. “I got off the phone and told them, ‘I just got a full ride to college,’” recalled Chupp. “Ty were like, ‘Oh my God, well, now it’s a celebration dinner.’”
That was 13 years ago. Today, the Oregon native, equipped with a bachelor’s degree in psychology and an MA in counseling from 91Ƶ, runs her own private practice, , as a licensed professional counselor. She credits 91Ƶ’s graduate counseling program with helping her reach her goals.
“I feel like what it gave me, in terms of my career, was a network and a level of trust, because the program is so respected,” Chupp said. “If you’re an 91Ƶ counseling grad, in this area, at least, it’s what gets you a job, no problem.”
Growing up in a Mennonite family, Chupp said her parents, graduates of Hesston and Goshen colleges, encouraged her to attend a Mennonite school. After visiting various colleges and universities across the U.S., she said 91Ƶ just felt different. Its students seemed the kindest, she said, and its campus the most active. The fact that she could earn a college degree without paying a dollar in tuition, thanks to 91Ƶ’s generous donors, was just the cherry on top.
“T Yoder/Webb scholarship ultimately sealed it,” she said. “How are you going to say no to that?”
While at 91Ƶ, Chupp studied in the Middle East for her intercultural in 2015 and attended the Y-Serve Civil Rights Tour in 2016. Both of those experiences wouldn’t have been possible for her without attending 91Ƶ, she said.
Another unique experience offered at 91Ƶ was the closeness she shared with her professors. “My classes were small enough that we were invited to professors’ homes for dinner, and we called them by their first names,” she said. “That’s not common. That’s something 91Ƶ does differently.”
She continues to stay in touch with many of them. “Ty’re not just former professors,” she said. “Ty’re friends who happened to be my professors.”
For the past five years, Chupp has been actively involved in the local roller derby community. She skates as Peaches n’ Scream for The Hits, a team that competes in Harrisonburg’s . She had attended games as an 91Ƶ student but was committed to theater. “Plus, my mom told me I couldn’t join until I was off her health insurance,” she joked. When COVID-19 put an end to her theater shows, she discovered a newfound passion on the roller rink.
“It’s a very inclusive and welcoming community,” said Chupp. “It’s a sport where every body type has a place and a purpose. There’s also something cathartic about it in that it’s curated aggression.”
Chupp has four siblings, including two alumni, Brandon ’19 and Caleb ’25. They aren’t the only Royals she may have helped recruit to campus. The longtime camp counselor and director spent many summers working at Drift Creek Camp, a Mennonite camp on the coast of Oregon. She said several former campers are now students at 91Ƶ. “When I came to 91Ƶ, I was the first Oregon student in years,” she said. “Tre was one senior and then me. And now, there’s a whole posse of them that are here.”
Since graduating from 91Ƶ in 2018, Chupp has regularly returned to campus to attend events, meet with friends, and provide services at the counseling center.
“It’s rewarding to still be part of the community and care about it,” she said. “I think it’s easy for alumni to dismiss it as something from when they were in college, but I continue to feel invested in 91Ƶ’s success.”
Your support helps students pursue a quality college education without financial barriers. Join us for the 10th annual Lov91Ƶ Giving Day and contribute to the scholarships that empower future 91Ƶ students. On April 1, let’s show that our generosity knows no bounds…for the record!

Thanks for this profile on Bethany! I already knew she was great, but I’m happy to hear more about her accomplishments. I first met her as a counselor for my kids at Drift Creek Camp and she was amazing back then too!